Checking in(ish): The Algonquin Resort, Saint Andrews, New Brunswick

Saint Andrews, New Brunswick has a long history as a playground for Canada’s upper class. Looking to escape the heat and humidity of the inland cities in the 1890s and later, the wealthy would ride the railroad east from Montreal and Toronto, arriving in New Brunswick and the shores of the Bay of Fundy. The wealthiest bought islands or built their own cottages in towns like St. Andrews while others would settle in at luxury hotels like the Algonquin Resort. A rail spur off the main Canada Pacific Rail line would bring guests between the coastal retreat and their real world homes to the west. Alas, the hotel struggled over the years and changed ownership several times, being purchased by the provincial government at one point to help keep the operation running. Most recently, in 2012, the Algonquin Resort was sold by the government to a group of private investors and reflagged under Marriott’s Autograph Collection brand. Following a massive, multi-year renovation the property is open once again.

This is a slightly different sort of hotel review in that we didn’t actually spend a night there. But we spent an afternoon exploring the public areas (including the bar) and got a feel for the place; it was enough (and this version of the hotel new enough) that I figured it was worth sharing some of my observations.

In front of the Algonquin Resort
In front of the Algonquin Resort, freshly renovated and still majestic

The renovations only slightly belie the original construction. Little things, like a waterslide poking through the walls at one point almost certainly weren’t part of the 1860s version of the blueprints. That’s actually part of a second building which was added to increase the room count from the original 80 to the current 200+.

No way that’s part of the 1889 version of the blueprints

But the other parts mostly maintain the classic, luxurious but not over-the-top vibe. The lobby bar and patio area was well appointed and most comfortable for enjoying an afternoon beer. Plus some cool artwork on display, too.

The main lobby area; great light and fun artwork throughout


Perfect setting for afternoon beers

Beyond that, the grounds were impeccably manicured. And considering that a tropical storm blew through only a couple days prior that is even more impressive.

Looking up to the Algonquin Resort, with the expansion off to the right
Looking up to the Algonquin Resort, with the expansion off to the right


There’s a separate outdoor pool area as well which was busy during our visit but didn’t seem overwhelmed at any point.

The pool area is separate from the main hotel building

As for the rooms, well, I have no idea what they’re like. We weren’t guests and never got inside one of them. Based on the rest of the renovations (and the photos I’ve seen on Marriott’s site) I’ll go ahead and assume that they are very nice but mostly like a Marriott room. Some suites have fireplaces, which is a nice touch in the winter, I presume.

The main street in St Andrews
The main waterfront street in St Andrews

The hotel is on the edge of town atop a hill. That provides it with commanding views out over the Bay of Fundy but also makes it a tiny bit out of the way for exploring the quaint resort town in which it sits. Really just a couple blocks of walking or a 5 minute drive will get you to the waterfront so it isn’t too bad and it is a very, very small town so having a self-contained resort is a good thing in many ways. And if you want to stroll into town the option is there.

If you’re going to be in the area and need a place to stay this probably is going to be one of your better options, if for no other reason than there really aren’t too many other options. Plus, the renovations have it looking spectacular.

Never miss another post: Sign up for email alerts and get only the content you want direct to your inbox.

Seth Miller

I'm Seth, also known as the Wandering Aramean. I was bit by the travel bug 30 years ago and there's no sign of a cure. I fly ~200,000 miles annually; these are my stories. You can connect with me on Twitter, Facebook, and LinkedIn.